Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Duffer's Mill

a view of a house

Hours & Location

1600 Naamans Creek Rd,
Garnet Valley, PA 19061
(610) 859-0011

Sunday - Wednesday
11:00 am - 12:30 am

Thursday - Saturday
11:00 am - 2:00 am

Duffer’s Mill, located on Naaman’s Creek Road on the PA/DE Border, in Chichester, PA, opened in 2009 and quickly a popular destination for delicious food, fun times and a great atmosphere. At "The Mill" you’ll be treated like our favorite “regular” even if it is your first visit.

Catering Private Events Menu

Get Directions

Appetizers

  • Homemade Chicken Fingers

    Chicken fingers w/ honey mustard

    $8.99

  • Cheesesteak Egg Rolls

    Philly style beef served w/ sriracha ketchup.

    $9.99

  • Korean BBQ Ribs

    Half rack of tender ribs, crispy fried & tossed in Korean bbq sauce.

    $13.99

  • Pizza Dip

    Pepperoni & mozzarella cheese folded w/ pizza sauce & cream cheese, served w/ house made herbed focaccia for dipping.

    $9.99

  • Shrimp Lejon

    Horseradish stuffed & bacon wrapped shrimp, fried & served w/ your choice of Russian dressing or dijon horseradish sauce.

    $12.99

  • Chorizo Nachos For 2

    Crispy corn tortillas topped w/ ground chorizo in a cheddar cheese cream sauce, salsa, & jalapenos and olives.

    $11.99

  • Stuffed Jalapenoes

    Jalapeños stuffed with cheddar cheese and wrapped in bacon.

    $8.99

  • Blackened Sirloin Tips

    Cajun Dusted Beef tips & served w/ chili blue cheese.

    $9.99

  • Fried Brussel Sprouts

    Tossed in soy sauce & garlic then drizzled w/ spicy mustard.

    $7.99

  • Pretzel Bites

    Soft pretzel bites served w/ cheese sauce for dipping.

    $5.99

  • Crabby Bites

    Soft Pretzel bites topped with crab meat, american cheese sauce and old bay.

    $10.99

  • Steamed Mussels

    One pound of mussels steamed in a tomato basil sauce served with a side of garlic bread.

    $10.99

  • Mozzarella Sticks

    6 Beer battered mozzarella sticks served w/ marinara sauce.

    $6.99

Fry Guys

Sub Tater Tots $1.00

  • Chili Cheese Fries

    House made chili & cheddar cheese sauce

    $4.49

  • Crabby Fries

    American cheese sauce & Old Bay seasoning

    $4.49

  • Sweet Potato Chips

    Served w/ horseradish sauce

    $5.99

  • Onion Rings

    Served w/ horseradish sauce

    $5.99

WINGS

  • BONE-IN

    (5) $6.49

  • BONELESS

    Orders by the 1/2 pound

    $8.99

  • SPICE 'EM UP W/ OUR SIGNATURE SAUCES

    Hot

    Mild

    Caribbean Jerk

    D’s Sweet Kick

    Bumble Bee

    Korean BBQ

    Garlic Parmesan

    Inferno

  • a plate of food with a fork
    Slide 1 of 2
  • a plate of food
    Slide 2 of 2

    • Salads

    • Duffer’s House Salad

      Crisp Romaine lettuce topped w/ cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, carrots & croutons.

      Small $5.49

      Large $6.99

    • Caesar Salad

      Crisp Romaine, Caesar dressing & croutons.

      Small $5.49

      Large $6.99

    Signature Salads

    • Grilled Chicken Cobb Salad

      Crisp Romaine lettuce topped w/ grilled chicken, crumbled blue cheese, tomato, bacon, egg, avocado & croutons.

      $12.99

    • Tri-color Salad

      Crisp spring greens, grilled chicken, dried cranberries, crumbled goat cheese & walnuts topped w/ red wine vinaigrette.

      $13.99

    • Mango Chicken Salad

      Spring greens, apple, dried cranberry, walnuts, onions & shredded carrots tossed in mango vinaigrette topped w/ blackened chicken.

      $13.99

    • Wedge Salad

      Crisp Iceberg wedge topped w/ bacon, red onions, crumbled blue cheese & diced tomato, served w/ your choice of dressing.

      $8.99

    • Add To Any Salad

      Chicken $3.99

      Shrimp $7.99

      Crab Cake $7.99

      Salmon $8.99

    • Dressing Choices

      Ranch, Oil & Vinegar, Italian, Honey Mustard, Blue Cheese, Mango Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette

    Soups

    • French Onion

      Crock

      $5.99

    • Home-Style Chili

      Our homemade chili in a French Onion crock topped w/ cheddar cheese, scallions & sour cream.

      $6.49

    • Homemade Soup Du Jour

      Market Price

    • Seasonal Crab Soup

      Cup $5.49

      Bowl $6.49

  • a white plate topped with different types of food
    Slide 1 of 2
  • a white plate topped with meat and vegetables
    Slide 2 of 2

    • Sandwiches

    All of our sandwiches come w/ house made potato chips.

    • Substitutions

      Fries or Tater Tots $1

      Onion Rings $2

      Sweet Potato Fries $3

    • Classic Hot Roast Beef

      Tender roast beef on an Italian roll w/ your choice of cheese

      $9.99

    • Crab Cake Sandwich

      Maryland-style broiled crab cake, served on a soft kaiser roll w/ your choice of tartar or cocktail sauce.

      $13.99

    • Reuben

      Thinly sliced corned beef on seeded rye bread w/ Swiss, sauerkraut & Thousand Island dressing.

      $9.99

    • Hot Roast Beef

      Slow roasted beef on a pub roll w/ your choice of cheese.

      $9.99

    • Chicken Avocado Ciabatta

      Grilled chicken, cilantro mayo, roasted corn salsa, avocado, pepper jack cheese & lettuce on a toasted ciabatta.

      $11.99

    • Chicken Salad Sandwich

      House made chicken salad on your choice of bread w/ lettuce & tomato.

      $9.99

    • Pulled Pork Sandwich

      Duffer’s slow roasted pork & our famous au-jus served on a seeded roll w/ your choice of cheese.

      $9.99

      Add Roasted Peppers or Long Hots $1.50

    • Salmon BLT

      Char-grilled salmon on rye toast, w/ bacon, spring greens, tomatoes & dill mayo.

      $14.99

    • Pretzel Sandwich

      Grilled smoked ham w/ bacon, honey mustard & cheddar cheese served on a grilled pretzel roll

      $9.99

    • Ham and Brie Panini

      Grill pressed ciabatta roll with raspberry dijon mustard, brie cheese, tavern ham, fig jam and apple wood bacon.

      $11.99

    • 3 Alarm Chicken Panini

      Cajun seared chicken served on a toasted ciabatta roll w/ chipotle mayonnaise, banana pepper relish, lettuce, tomato and pepper jack cheese.

      $12.99

    • Piggly Wiggly

      Cheddar Jalapeno Brioche roll w, pulled pork, chopped baby back ribs and candied pork belly drizzled with sriracha bbq sauce.

      $12.99

    Burgers & Cheese Steaks

    All of our burgers come as a choice of an 8 oz. special blend patty, or 6 oz. Chicken Breast. Lettuce, tomato & onion available upon request. | All of our sandwiches come w/ house made potato chips.

    • Substitutions

      Fries or Tater Tots $1

      Onion Rings $2

      Sweet Potato Fries $3

    • Classic Burger

      Our House Blend Burger w/ your choice of cheese.

      $9.99

    • Jack Daniels Burger

      8oz grilled sirloin patty served on a pub roll topped with jack daniels bbq sauce, pickles, bacon and cheddar cheese.

      $12.99

    • Kennet Burger

      Topped w/ herb roasted mushrooms & horseradish cheddar

      $10.99

    • Smokehouse

      Dry Rubbed then topped w/ BBQ sauce, bacon, jalapenos & pepper jack cheese

      $12.99

    • Philly Burger

      Served on a grilled pretzel roll w/ fried onions & cheddar cheese sauce.

      $11.99

    • Philly Cheesesteak

      12oz of your choice of beef or chicken, chopped Philly style on a long roll w/ your choice of cheese & toppings.

      $11.99

    • Sliders

      3 mini versions of our fresh ground sirloin burger

      $9.99

    • Add To Your Burger

      Smoked Bacon $1.99

      House made bacon jam $1.99

      Fried egg for $1

      Herb Roasted Mushrooms $1

  • a sandwich sitting on top of a table
    Slide 1 of 2
  • a box filled with different types of food on a plate
    Slide 2 of 2

    • Entrees

    Add a Side Salad or Soup for just $3.99

    • Pierogies and Kielbasa

      Pan seared pierogies topped with fried onions and kielbasa in a caraway butter sauce.

      $11.99

    • Shrimp and Pasta

      Sauteed shrimp tossed with broccoli and cavatappi pasta in a roasted garlic cream sauce.

      $16.99

    • Crab Cake Dinner

      One of our house made Maryland style crab cakes, served w/ your choice of cocktail or tartar sauce.

      $15.99

      Add another crab cake for $7.99

    • Cedar Plank Salmon

      Lemon & herb butter Atlantic salmon steak grilled on a cedar plank. Served w/ vegetable & potato du jour.

      $18.99

    • Parmesan Chicken

      Hand breaded chicken breast topped w/ spinach & diced tomatoes in an asiago cream sauce served over linguini.

      $14.99

    • Blackened Chicken & Pierogies

      Cajun seared chicken served w / potato stuffed pierogis tossed w/ peppers & onions in a shallot cream sauce.

      $15.99

    • Mom's Meatloaf

      Homemade meatloaf topped with brown gravy served with vegetable and potato Du jour.

      $14.99

    • BBQ Ribs

      Brown sugar and coffee rubbed, slow roasted, baby back ribs topped with BBQ sauce served with cole slaw and french fries

      Half Rack $15.99

      Add another half rack $7.99

    • Grilled Ribeye

      12oz Ribeye served with vegetable and potato du jour.

      $18.99

  • a plate of food with a fork
    Slide 1 of 2
  • a plate of food with a fork and knife
    Slide 2 of 2

    • Tacos & Quesadillas

    Choose the following as a quesadilla or three soft flour tacos.

    • Smoked Brisket

      Smoked brisket w/ cheddar jack cheese, shredded cabbage, carrots & sweet & smokey ranch.

      $13.99

    • Carolina Pork

      Smoked pork belly,Carolina gold BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese and cole slaw.

      $11.99

    • Mahi Mahi

      Pan seared Mahi Mahi w/ lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cilantro lime crema.

      $12.99

    • Italian Quesadilla

      Parmesan encrusted tortilla w/ grilled chicken, roasted peppers, onions & mozzarella cheese served w/ marinara sauce.

      $10.99

    • Pulled Chipotle Chicken

      Chipotle pulled chicken w/ peppers, onions & cheddar jack cheese.

      $9.99

    • Blackened Shrimp

      Cajun seared shrimp w/ avocado slaw & mango salsa.

      $12.99

    Kid’s Menu

    All kids meals are 5.99 & come w/ one side & choice of drink

    • Side Choices:

      Potato of the Day, Broccoli, French Fries, Apple Sauce

    • Drink Choices:

      Juice, Milk, Soda

    • Spaghetti w/ marinara

    • Spaghetti w/ meat sauce

    • Mac & Cheese

    • Burger Sliders

    • Hot Dog

    • French Bread Pizza

    • Chicken Nuggets

    • Grilled Cheese

    Signature Desserts

    • Strawberry Shortcake

      Fresh sliced pound cake layered w/ strawberries & whip cream.

      $5.99

    • Brownie Sundae

      Warm brownie topped w/ ice cream & whip cream.

      $5.99

    • Cheesecake

      Creamy house made cheesecakew/ a graham cracker crust.

      $5.99

    • Ice Cream Sandwich

      Vanilla ice cream sandwiched between chocolate chip cookies then rolled in chocolate chips.

      $5.99

    • Oreo Sundae

      Crushed Oreos served over your choice of ice-cream topped w/ whipped cream.

      $5.99

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!

    Reservations

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thanks!